Vance says the ball is in Iran's court after tense talks in Islamabad
The vice president returned from Pakistan saying progress was made, but now it's up to Tehran to respond as a U.S. blockade tightens
At a glance
What matters most
- Vice President JD Vance says the U.S. has fulfilled its opening commitments in Iran talks, now urging Tehran to respond.
- A U.S. naval blockade in the Strait of Hormuz is now active, increasing pressure on Iran's oil exports.
- The talks, held in Islamabad, involved special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner alongside Vance.
- Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called the negotiations a 'joke' and said President Trump is 'fully unhinged.'
Across the spectrum
What people are saying
A quick look at how the same story is being framed from different angles.
On the Left
Critics on the left see the Vance-led talks as a dangerous mix of amateur diplomacy and military posturing. They argue that bypassing career diplomats and relying on political allies undermines credibility, while the blockade risks provoking conflict rather than preventing it. Clinton's criticism reflects a broader concern: that treating high-stakes negotiations like political theater sacrifices long-term stability for short-term headlines.
In the Center
From a centrist perspective, the administration is using calibrated pressure to create space for diplomacy. The blockade is a serious move, but not an act of war - it's designed to incentivize talks, not replace them. The involvement of Kushner and Witkoff may be unorthodox, but past administrations have also used backchannels. The real test will be whether Iran responds and whether any agreement can be sustained beyond the current political cycle.
On the Right
Supporters on the right view Vance's approach as strong, decisive leadership. They see the blockade as a necessary tool to counter Iranian aggression and believe past diplomacy failed by being too soft. Using trusted envoys instead of bureaucratic holdovers is seen as efficient and loyal. From this angle, Clinton's criticism is dismissed as partisan noise from a failed foreign policy era that the current administration is trying to move beyond.
Full coverage
What you should know
Vice President JD Vance returned from Islamabad this weekend saying the U.S. has made its opening play in renewed talks with Iran, and now it's Tehran's turn to act. Speaking after a closed-door meeting with Iranian officials, Vance said the American delegation - which included special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner - made headway on de-escalation, but only if Iran chooses to follow through. 'The ball is in their court,' Vance said, standing beside U.S. naval forces now enforcing a partial blockade in the Strait of Hormuz.
The blockade, which began quietly late last week, restricts Iranian oil shipments and has already driven global energy prices slightly higher. The administration frames it as leverage, not aggression - a way to push Iran toward negotiations without direct conflict. Officials say the goal is to limit Iran's ability to fund regional proxies while leaving a clear path to diplomacy. But the move has drawn sharp reactions, especially from critics who say it risks miscalculation in one of the world's most volatile waterways.
The Islamabad meeting was unusual in both location and personnel. Pakistan, not typically a mediator in U.S.-Iran talks, hosted the session as a neutral ground. The American team leaned on Kushner and Witkoff, both longtime Trump allies with informal influence, rather than traditional State Department channels. That bypassing of career diplomats has raised eyebrows among foreign policy veterans, who question the depth and sustainability of any agreement reached through backchannel talks.
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton was blunt in her criticism. Appearing on MSNBC, she called the administration's approach 'a joke' and said President Trump's recent rhetoric - including inflammatory posts about Iran and the Pope - shows he's 'fully unhinged.' She questioned the credibility of talks led by political loyalists instead of experienced diplomats, saying, 'You can't run foreign policy like a real estate deal.' Her comments reflect broader skepticism among some foreign policy experts about the administration's mix of bluster and backroom negotiation.
Still, the White House insists the strategy is working. Officials say Iran has signaled quiet interest in continuing talks, especially as economic pressure mounts. The blockade isn't total - humanitarian goods are still allowed through - but it's tight enough to hurt. Oil analysts estimate Iran's export revenue could drop by 30% in the next quarter if the restrictions hold.
Vance acknowledged the risks but said the U.S. is acting with restraint. 'We're not looking for war,' he said. 'But we're not going to let Iran destabilize the region unchecked.' He added that the administration is prepared to ease the blockade if Iran agrees to verifiable limits on its nuclear program and reduces support for armed groups in Yemen, Syria, and Lebanon.
What happens next likely depends on how Iran chooses to respond. If they engage, it could open a rare window for diplomacy. If they don't, the U.S. may tighten the screws further - or face pressure to back down. For now, the administration is waiting, watching, and keeping its fleet in place.
About this author
Zwely News Staff compiles multi-source reporting into concise, viewpoint-aware coverage for readers who want context without noise.
Source Notes
Vance says 'the ball is in Iran's court' to move peace talks further, as U.S. blockade takes effect
The U.S. team of Vance and special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner made progress with Iran during the Islamabad talks, the vice president said.
‘Ball Is in Their Court’: Vance Addresses Future Talks With Iran
After returning from negotiations with Iranian officials in Pakistan, Vice President JD Vance said the next step toward future negotiations lies with Iran. “It’s a... Read More The post ‘Ball Is in Their Court’: Vance Addresses Future Talks...
Hillary Clinton mocks Vance-led Iran peace talks as ‘joke’ diplomacy
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton derided the Trump administration’s handling of high-stakes peace talks with Iran, calling the effort led by Vice President JD Vance “a joke” and questioning the administration’s ability to conduct s...
Hillary Clinton says Trump ‘fully unhinged,’ Vance-led Iran talks ‘a joke’
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton took President Trump to task on Monday for a spate of “unhinged” social media posts and slammed his administration’s approach to negotiations with Iran. Speaking to hosts Joe Scarborough and Mika Br...
Previous story
Péter Magyar steps in as Hungary's new prime minister after Orbán's long run ends
Next story